Thursday, December 11, 2014

TV Review: Sons of Anarchy, Series Ending (Papa's Goods) Episode Review


Sons of Anarchy (2008 - 2014), Series Ending Episode (Papa’s Goods)

Three and half Stars out of Five

TV MA LSV (Language, Sexual situations, Violence)

Crime/Drama

Jackson Teller: Charlie Hunnam
Gemma Teller: Katey Sagal
Creator/Writer: Kurt Sutter

Most of the best stories being written and broadcast on television have for the past decade been violent, often to an extreme. In some cases such as Breaking Bad, Deadwood or The Walking Dead, the violence is as essential to the story line as the lead character. In other equally good stories (such as Homeland or The Wire), violence plays a role but is generally pushed into the background being used only when essential. The prominence with which violence is used in the recently concluded Sons of Anarchy series is as astonishing as its literal or metaphorical purpose is mysterious. To be sure, the outlaw biker life depicted in the program is likely a violent one, but the extreme level of it that is used by program creator Kurt Sutter begs to be explained. Is it merely seven seasons of gratuitous violence, or is Sutter seeking a deeper, more nuanced meaning? In the early seasons, I had hoped for subtlety, but with the concluding episode shown on FX this past Tuesday (9Dec2014), I have to conclude a gratuitous use of violence would have been preferable to the cloudy thinking that went into the frankly sacrilegious comparison of lead character Jackson Teller’s actions to those of Jesus Christ.

Season seven was cleverly (if with extreme and brutal violence) set up with the murder of Teller’s wife, Tara (Maggie Siff) by his mom Gemma (Katey Sagal). Gemma is saved from prosecution by Teller’s biker teammate, Juice (Theo Rossi). Throughout season seven, Gemma and Juice maintain their charade even as Jax starts multiple gangland wars based on his mother’s and Juice’s lies as to who was responsible for Tara’s murder. When the truth is finally revealed to Jax, he starts a program to wrap up various loose ends with his motorcycle club, friends and family. The audience is given an opportunity to witness just how ruthless and morally decrepit Jax has become. As in the previous six seasons, Jax employs his sociopathic genius to reach his goals; all but one that is. And that one is his own fate. He comes to the conclusion he is a danger to his two boys. He deposits them with the mother of the elder boy, Wendy (Drea de Matteo), and then he sets off to end his own life. Is this intended to be Jax’s redemption?

Sutter attempts to excuse Jax' depredations over the previous seven seasons in a less than artful manner via his suicide/self-sacrifice. Near the story’s end, Jax encounters a homeless woman that had been shown in previous episodes mystically appearing and disappearing without explanation. She leaves her bread and wine to give Jax her blanket and tells him it is time to end it. Having received this permission/guidance from this Mary-like character, Jax collects the lives (and presumably the souls) of the two thieves that will accompany him to the hereafter; one August Marks (Billy Brown) nods his acceptance of Jax, while the second thief, Charles Barosky (Peter Weller) is gunned down without comment. Jax fleeing the police he himself has set on his tail decides suicide-by-cop is taking too much time and as such, stretches his arms out crucifixion-style to run his motorcycle headlong into a truck, whose driver’s only words are “Jesus”. The final scene is a close up on two crows picking at a piece of wine-stained bread – just in case anyone missed the first allusion to bread and wine.

Has there ever been a weaker, more offensive attempt to excuse homicidal behavior than this awful attempt to write off a killer’s countless murders with a comparison of his suicide to the sacrifice made on the cross by Jesus? Consider also his mother’s self-delusional excuse for her murder of Tara: she was looking out for her family. Later, she tells Jax that she actually really loved Tara and gives him permission to kill/execute her; which, of course, he does. It would appear there is  never any other course of action in life; is murder the only path forward. One might presume Jax has inherited his mother’s flawed view of life (especially the lives of others) and her unbelievably feeble excuse, “it’s what we do”. Are these characters humans or animals, incapable of thought and reason? Seven seasons of endless and pointless death describe this series. If it had been merely the pointless, car chase with bad music kind of violence (featured so prominently in season four), one could write the series off as just another TV version of a b-movie or even more to the point, a video game. But really, Sutter clearly aspires to something higher; he tries to give some meaning to the endless death and violence in his series. To my mind, he tries but falls short. His violence has become in the end nothing more than an addictive drug; there is no meaning, only a seven year failed effort. And just like some desperate junkie with an outstretched arm begging for more of their drug of choice, and then dies in some nameless alley, this series will just fade away, forgotten, leaving not a trace of meaning.



No comments:

Post a Comment