Sunday, March 1, 2015

Book Review: Song of Solomon by Toni Morrison


Song of Solomon (1977)

Five Stars out of Five

Toni Morrison

Toni Morrison uses one of the most distinctive and beautiful writing styles of any author from the 20th century as she explores the African-American and female experience in racially divided America. She tells through the poetry of her language the story of African-Americans’ search for their own identity and place in the world, a world that has robbed them of their culture, their language, even their names. In her 1993 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel “Song of Solomon”, she has achieved a pinnacle of story-telling that places this book according to some in the publishing industry in the Top Twenty-five list for best English language books.

“Song of Solomon” tells the story of Macon Dead III (aka Milkman) from his birth in 1930’s Michigan to his ambiguous ending/transformation in 1960’s Virginia. Milkman is the descendant of a legendary slave named Solomon, Milkman’s great-grandfather. Working forward in time, we are introduced to Macon Dead I, Solomon’s 21st child and Milkman’s grandfather. Macon Dead’s name came to him and his descendants via a clerical error following their emancipation from slavery. Macon I is assassinated by a family of former slave owners (ironically named the "Butlers"), but not before fathering Macon II and his sister, Pilate (named from the Bible like all of Macon I descendants, except from the Macon’s). Macon II and his wife Ruth are the parents of Macon III, more generally known as Milkman.

Besides the wonderfully poetic language used by Morrison in “Song of Solomon”, she tells a story steeped in biblical allusions. The Song of Songs (or Song of Solomon or Canticles) occurs in the latter part of the Old Testament (or Ketuvim in the Hebrew bible). Like Morrison’s book, the biblical book uses poetic language to tell a story; a story that celebrates sexual love; a love that could be compared to death in that it is relentless and jealous, one that cannot be refused. In the biblical story, an unnamed woman, self-described as black from the sun, is a powerful, guiding force whose passion will not be denied. The parallels in Morrison’s story to Pilate’s dominating presence and Hagar’s all-consuming and eventual self-destructive obsession over Milkman are hard to ignore.

Another aspect of Morrison’s novel that helps place this book in the top tier of fiction is her use of a narration style that is a variation of the omniscient viewpoint. This allows Morrison to give the internal dialog for the various characters within the book, thus helping to elucidate their motivations and thoughts. Such clarity is essential to give the reader, especially the White-reader such as myself some degree of insight to the African-American perspective to life in 20th century America. I also was intrigued by Morrison’s occasional use (in my opinion) of the magical realism motif made famous by Gabriel Garcia Márquez. In Morrison’s case she actually foreshadows it use with the opening attempt by the frustrated (confused/demented?) insurance salesman, Robert Smith and his attempt to fly from a church steeple. Much later in the book, we see a more successful use of flight by Solomon and at the very end a more metaphorical use by Milkman as he makes his final confrontation with former friend, now enemy Guitar.

The complexity of “Song of Solomon” is further enhanced by Morrison’s use of allusion and symbolism via her naming of the various characters. A good example is Circe, the former slave of the Butlers who helps Macon II and Pilate escape the Butlers after their murder of Macon I. Consider Circe’s use of magic in Greek mythology and her “association” with animals versus Morrison’s Circe’s extreme age and her care-taking of the Butlers and later after the last Butler death, of a pack of dogs (surely metaphors for Butlers). Another example is the case of Macon II and his life-long struggle to live up to his father’s successes through his own pursuit of money; it is an easy interpretation to link his surname of “Dead” to his own spiritual death. But my favorite example is Ruth. Ruth is a very clever a reference to the Ruth of the bible (yet another book from the Ketuvim). The biblical Ruth was the model for loving kindness; one who also accepted a lower social status by working in the fields. Morrison’s Ruth not only accepted the “step-down” from being daughter of the most respected man in town (the only Black doctor) to being the wife of a rent collector (Macon II), she also personified her loving nature via her too-close relationship to Macon III (at least in part demonstrated by nursing him to age four or five, and of course leading to his nick name of Milkman). And Ruth helps Morrison further define the color consciousness of the African-American community as she is considered “high yellow” in color and in status, and like the biblical Ruth makes the “your people shall be my people” transition, in this case by joining the darker-skinned Macon Dead family and community.


The “Song of Solomon” is a terrifically complex novel. It is a story about race, family, and women. The women in the story range from the mystical Pilate, to the inhibited Reba, to the obsessive Hagar, and ultimately to the disconsolate and self-sacrificing Ruth. Like the biblical books Song of Solomon and Ruth, the reader will gain not only an appreciation of African-American life, but also of the particular effects that life has on its female members. This book can be read for the beauty of its language and construction, for its biblical allusions, for its insight into the condition and reaction of the African-American community, or even for the surface story of Milkman’s life story and his transition from a self-centered permanent adolescent to an actualized adult. For any or all of these reasons, “Song of Solomon” is a book well worth reading by all adult Americans.

No comments:

Post a Comment