Beloved (1987)
Four and Half Stars out of Five
Toni Morrison
The question of whether or not of whether America is “post-racial”
is one that has come up many times since the presidential election of Barak Obama in 2008.
And in one sense it is one of several themes that run through Toni Morrison’s
1987 novel “Beloved”. This tragic story of the direct and indirect effects of
slavery on African-Americans has rarely if ever been told in a more trenchant
and disturbing manner than in this novel. How could a young mother be so pushed
to the edges of fear and desperation as to feel that her children’s best hope
was to die by her hand rather than to be returned to slavery? How can America
so badly remember, so badly misunderstand the effects of slavery and the 150
years of ongoing bias and persecution of a people?
Morrison employs her form of magical realism coupled with a non-linear
technique of story-telling in “Beloved”. The non-linearity and the multiple-narrative prose that she uses is such that many readers will find this
book a daunting challenge just from a structural perspective alone. “Beloved”
is based on the true story of Margaret Garner. She was an escaped slave from
Kentucky that was returned from Ohio courtesy of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850.
In Morrison’s story, Sethe the mother of two boys (Howard and Buglar) and one 2
year girl (“already crawling baby”/Beloved), and pregnant with her second daughter,
Denver escapes from the Sweet Home plantation in Kentucky. Following her
horrific rape and whipping at the hands of a local known as School Teacher, she
reaches Cincinnati and the home of her husband’s mother, Baby Suggs. Following
28 days of freedom, a search team has found her and aims to return her and the
children to Kentucky. Sethe intends to kill all of her children to prevent such
a life being once more forced on them. She kills only the two year old girl, "already crawling baby". Since all
are considered property she is not sentenced for murder but only for the
destruction of property. She exits jail after a few years to the widespread
rejection of the Black community in Cincinnati. Baby Suggs takes her back in and
provides her shelter at 124 Bluestone Road.
The home at 124 Bluestone Road becomes haunted with a spirit;
“124 was spiteful. Full of a baby’s venom”. (The home at 124 Bluestone Road is
such a singular literary invention that in “Beloved” it assumes the role of another
character in the book; it is clearly one manifestation of the Beloved character
and all she stands for.) In time, Paul D, a brother of Sethe’s lost husband and
father to her children (Halle) arrives at the house on 124 Bluestone Road. He
drives off the spirit, but in her place shortly thereafter appears a young
Black woman who claims with halting speech the name of Beloved. The now grown
second daughter of Sethe, Denver recognizes almost immediately that this is the lost baby, but in an adult's body. Neither Paul D nor Sethe draw the same conclusion
initially, though Paul D is compelled to the leave the house by seemingly
supernatural means. In time, Sethe recognizes Beloved as her lost child, the
child she killed with a hand saw’s slice across the throat. Following Paul D’s
departure, life and the narrative style at 124 Bluestone Road become chaotic, almost hallucinogenic.
Eventually, Beloved departs and a sense of normality
returns.
Of the themes that run through “Beloved”, the racial divide
between Black and White people is the one that I cannot but think is the most
dominant message to be grasped at by a white man such as myself. In
contemporary events, one sees almost daily news reports of the trials young Black
men in America face: pointlessly being stopped in traffic by the police, being
asked for receipts for bicycles that they are riding when stopped, being shot
to death (or strangled or having their necks broken) when unarmed and being
guilty in many cases of being black and little else. As damaging as this
situation is in early 21st century America, one still does not get
even a glimpse the depth of the divide between the races as seen from the
Black perspective in “Beloved”. Reading the descriptions of the surrounding “whitepeople”
and their communities on the Black community, one could easily be forgiven for
drawing the conclusion that the two races in question were neither of the same
species or even the same planet. The slaves and former slaves in “Beloved”
speak with unerring consistency of the craziness of the “whitepeople”; not
their lack of morality, but their craziness. The behavior of the oppressive
race on the oppressed is so far from the latter’s understanding, they don’t even try
to explain it in terms of a lack of morality. It simply makes so little sense,
the “whitepeople” can only be thought of as deranged.
The concept of an isolated and self-sufficient Black
community is another theme that runs through “Beloved” as well. There is a
sense of morality, of acceptance for some acts and not for others that stand
alone from any judgement from the outside White community. If Sethe’s actions were to
be best understood by any people, then surely the former slaves of Cincinnati
would be that people. But they reject Sethe’s murder of her infant daughter by
isolating her for over 10 years, the entire youth of Denver, Sethe’s youngest
daughter. Yet when Denver does leave her
home at 124 Bluestone Road due to starvation, she is readily supported by that
same surrounding Black community. They won’t let her pay for the food she needs, but
they will give it to her. And finally during the climatic closing scenes, a
group of Black women that had tolerated the malevolent spirit within the house will not
tolerate the danger that same spirit made manifest in the adult Beloved poses for
Denver, for Sethe, for the community and its sense of right and wrong.
From the community’s sense of self the story also delves
deeply into the individual’s sense of self. Each of the Black characters in “Beloved”
is a slave or a former slave at some point in the book’s narrative. Each of
these individuals carries acutely awful memories of the treatment while slaves:
Sethe’s whipping and loss of her baby’s milk, Halle’s silent witness of those
events, Paul D’s multiple attempts at escape and the metal chain around his
neck once re-captured, Baby Suggs’ poorly mended broken hip; the list goes on and on for each. Each of these former slaves carries memories that are so painful,
they must suppress them with “re-memories”. This is an attempt to create a
reality they can live with, but one that prevents them from being truly who
they are. Each of these people has their own brand of “craziness”; it is the
only way they believe they can survive.
For Sethe, Beloved and Denver the problem is most acute.
The early parts of the book describe with astonishing pain the loss that Sethe
feels when her milk for the infant Beloved is stolen from her. She has just
been raped and whipped nearly to death, but she is heard only lamenting the
loss of the milk. She has had a vitally important connection to her daughter
taken from her. It is perhaps a metaphor for all the family disruptions that
took place for slaves when their owners would sell their children to another
plantation. Again this sense that the owing race was in fact acting as if they
were two species instead of one, but for Sethe and her contemporaries, it was
far more personal. The connection between a mother and her child has few
parallels in human life, and it has just been cavalierly destroyed with as
little compassion as if the owner had sold some livestock.
So, is the adult Beloved the physical manifestation of the
spirit that once haunted 124 Bluestone Road or is she another lost child
looking for her mother? A case can be made for either explanation. There is
little doubt by the views of the household members of 124 Bluestone Road (or of
the surrounding community) that the house was haunted. There is the apparent
cut on the adult Beloved’s neck and her initial halting speech and walk that
would suggest she is still learning how to talk and walk (just as a baby). And
there is Morrison’s persistent use of Magical Realism as her genre of choice. A
ghost story with deeper layers is not at all beyond her reach. At yet, consider
the novel's inclusion of story from a youth having seen a naked woman running from 124 Bluestone Road
on the day Beloved disappears. And also consider the wider implications of
multiple mothers and daughters looking for lost daughters and mothers following
the civil war. The story is compelling from either point view, as an allegory
or as a description of a wide spread horror with few parallels in history;
certainly few in American history.
“Beloved” ends with an epigraph from Romans 9:25: As indeed
he says in Hosea, “Those who were not my people, I will call my people, and her
who was not beloved, I will call ‘beloved’”. Could there be a more compelling,
more human plea for compassion and recognition of a people to be treated and
considered human by all that surround them? Not just say that they are equal and regarded as so, but also to love and
accept them as so. “Beloved” won the Pulitzer Prize for fiction 1988 and has
been voted the best American novel for the period of 1981-2006. It is indeed a difficult
book to work through, but like James Joyce’s Ullysses (with whom it shares some
structural similarities) this is a book well worth making the effort to do so.
No comments:
Post a Comment